• MarxMadness@lemmygrad.ml
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    10
    ·
    10 days ago

    One of that organization’s source links is dead, the other is here. Haven’t had time to read through it all to see if the claims about conviction rates stand up.

    Also ran across this site. Not sure how reliable it is, but it does not appear to be friendly towards the PRC. This part was interesting:

    Chinese prosecutors tend to explain low acquittal rates as an indicator of good work. In 2012, a Beijing prosecutor told Legal Daily that a high level of “judicial precision” allowed good prosecutors to “filter out” cases likely to result in acquittal so that the majority of people standing trial were “guilty"…

    Local procuratorates followed suit by putting forth “zero acquittals” as the ultimate goal in their annual work reports. Among various performance indicators, the acquittal rate was the most important, legal scholar Yuan Yicheng told Legal Daily in 2012.

    Rather than risk acquittal, it is an unspoken rule that prosecutors decide to withdraw indictments.

    The approach seems to be to only prosecute cases you’re sure you’ll win. This is largely the approach in the U.S. federal system, and is pretty prevalent among state and local prosecutors, too.